Handle Turkish uppercase and lowercase correctly, need to modify/override built-in functions?

Question

I am working with multilingual text data, among others with Russian using the Cyrillic alphabet and Turkish. I basically have to compare the words in two files my_file and check_file and if the words in my_file can be found in check_file, write them in an output file keeping the meta-information about these words from both input files.

Some words are lowercased while other words are capitalised so I have to lowercase all the words to compare them. As I use Python 3.6.5 and Python 3 uses unicode as default, it handles lowercasing and later on capitalising the words correctly for Cyrillic. For Turkish however, some letters are not handled correctly. Uppercase 'İ' should correspond to lowercase 'i', uppercase 'I' should correspond to lowercase 'ı' and lowercase 'i' should correspond to uppercase 'İ' which is not the case if I type the following in the console:

>>> print('İ'.lower())
i̇  # somewhat not rendered correctly, corresponds to unicode 'i\u0307'
>>> print('I'.lower())
i
>>> print('i'.upper())
I

I am doing as follows (simplified sample code):

# python my_file check_file language

import sys

language = sys.argv[3]

# code to get the files as lists

my_file_list = [['ıspanak', 'N'], ['ısır', 'N'], ['acık', 'V']]
check_file_list = [['109', 'Ispanak', 'food_drink'], ['470', 'Isır', 'action_words'], [409, 'Acık', 'action_words']]

# get the lists as dict
my_dict = {}
check_dict = {}

for l in my_file_list:
    word = l[0].lower()
    pos = l[1]
    my_dict[word] = pos

for l in check_file_list:
    word_id = l[0]
    word = l[1].lower()
    word_cat = l[2]
    check_dict[word] = [word_id, word_cat]

# compare the two dicts
for word, pos in my_dict.items():
    if word in check_dict:
        word_id = check_dict[word][0]
        word_cat = check_dict[word][1]
        print(word, pos, word_id, word_cat)

This gives me only one result but it should give me the three words as result:

acık V 409 action_words

What I've done so far based on this question:

Read the accepted answer which proposes to use PyICU but I want my code to be useable without people having to install stuff so I didn't implement it.
Tried to import locale and locale.setlocale(locale.LC_ALL, 'tr_TR.UTF-8') as mentionned in the question but it didn't change anything.

Implement two functions turkish_lower(self) and turkish_upper(self) for the three problematic letters as described in the second answer which seems to be the only solution:

def turkish_lower(self):
    self = re.sub(r'İ', 'i', self)
    self = re.sub(r'I', 'ı', self)
    self = self.lower()
    return self

def turkish_upper(self):
    self = re.sub(r'i', 'İ', self)
    self = self.upper()
    return self

But how can I use these two functions without having to check if language == 'Turkish' every time? Should I override the built-in functions lower() and upper()? If yes, what is the pythonic way of doing it? Should I implement classes for the various languages I'm working with and override the built-in functions inside the class for Turkish?

implement `to_lower` and `to_upper` methods and language as parameter. Best way is using `icu`, dependencies are inevitable — adnbsr, May 02 '18 at 13:08
Could you possibly clarify how to do so? My goal is to be able to use `word = word.lower()` without having to clarify `if language == 'Turkish: word = turkish_lower(word[0])+word[1:] else word = word.lower()` in every for loops I'm using — Fable, May 02 '18 at 14:33
python does not support extension as swift. If you want to use `lower()`, you have to create your own type (class) and check language. In every case you have O(n) complexity, so choose one way — adnbsr, May 02 '18 at 15:22
This may help: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/19703106/python-and-turkish-capitalization — sardok, Jun 29 '18 at 15:22

score 1 · Answer 1 · answered Dec 15 '19 at 23:12

You can create a simple "language aware" string that subclasses str and will do the proper uppercasing and lowercasing, for example:

class LanguageAwareStr(str):
    lang = None


class RussianStr(LanguageAwareStr):
    lang = 'ru'


class TurkishStr(LanguageAwareStr):
    lang = 'tr'

    _case_lookup_upper = {'İ': 'i', 'I': 'ı'}  # lookup uppercase letters
    _case_lookup_lower = {v: k for (k, v) in _case_lookup_upper.items()}

    # here we override the lower() and upper() methods
    def lower(self):
        chars = [self._case_lookup_upper.get(c, c) for c in self]
        result = ''.join(chars).lower()
        cls = type(self)  # so we return a TurkishStr result
        return cls(result)

    def upper(self):
        chars = [self._case_lookup_lower.get(c, c) for c in self]
        result = ''.join(chars).upper()
        cls = type(self)  # so we return a TurkishStr result
        return cls(result)

Then when you read a string, knowing what language it is, you wrap it in the proper LanguageAwareStr subclass, and then just use it regularly:


from langaware import RussianStr, TurkishStr

if language == 'turkish':
    LangStr = TurkishStr  # can also create a dict to lookup the correct class

Then when you read language strings, you simply wrap them in a call to LangStr():

for l in my_file_list:
    word = LangStr(l[0]).lower()
    pos = l[1]
    my_dict[word] = pos

for l in check_file_list:
    word_id = l[0]
    word = LangStr(l[1]).lower()
    word_cat = l[2]
    check_dict[word] = [word_id, word_cat]

score 0 · Answer 2 · answered Jun 29 '18 at 13:27

I would suggest trying install the turkish language pack for locale:

sudo apt-get install language-pack-tr
sudo dpkg-reconfigure locales  # *

You can also check which languages you have in locale using the terminal command: $ locale -a

https://forum.yazbel.com/t/cozuldu-locale-setlocale-locale-lc-all-tr-tr-yapisinda-sorun-yasiyorum-turkce-karakter-sorunu/476

Handle Turkish uppercase and lowercase correctly, need to modify/override built-in functions?

2 Answers2

Linked