After looking through the CPython quite a lot and coming back to some other solutions (especially Import arbitrary python source file. (Python 3.3+)), I realized that I needed to pass the full path to my module. Here is the cross-platform, call-location-independent solution:
"""
import os, sys # For running from Notepad++ shortcut, etc
import importlib.machinery
program_1_4 = importlib.machinery.SourceFileLoader('program_1.4', os.path.join(sys.path[0], 'program_1.4.py')).load_module()
print(program_1_4)
program_1_4.main()
"""