Long polling with codeigniter and node.js

Question

I am in a position of researching new technologies , so I heard something about Long polling,node.js.

I need to create a web application that which use long polling.

On each and every page of this project i need to use polling , actually it checks if there is a new Email through POP.

So I think that I need to do the following

Call a ajax request to the server
Server receives the request and checks if there is a new Email
If there is a new Mail server responds with its details
If there is no new Email server started sleeping sometime and checking again until one new Email arrives.

so something like this

$(document).ready(function(){

is_there_new_mail();

function is_there_new_mail()
{

$.get(url,function(data){

if(data ==true)
{
//do some actions and call again
is_there_new_mail();
}


});


}


});

and in server something like this

   function check_mail()
    {

    //processing and checking is there a new mail on inbox 

    return $is_mail = $this->_new_mail()?true:false;

    }

    function receiver()
    {
    if($check_mail())
    {
     //send to client..
    }
    else

    {
    //sleep sometime and call mail function
    }

}

I heard that doing something like this will open many connection on server, and if we use node.js we can manage it with in one connection.

I am using Codeigniter, and really new to node.js.

How can I implement node.js with codeigniter, or could you please suggest me something more about this scenario.

With your explanation of your solution, it'll open up a new connection for each user that needs to long poll. There's really no better alternative, you can't have one single connection that handles all incoming client connections. — Sean Johnson, Jun 24 '12 at 14:22
What i understand is each request will make a new process on apache... how can i get rid of this ? [i am sorry,i am just researching about this ,the info may incorrect] — Red, Jun 24 '12 at 14:35

score 3 · Accepted Answer · edited May 23 '17 at 11:48

Its not such that node will handle all the requests in one connection. Node can handle large number of concurrent connection at a time, where Apache in other hands can only handle very few concurrent connections as compared to node.js

Look into websockets http://socket.io/ .

Websockets allow full duplex connections between the client and the server. HTTP protocol opens up a connection for each request and the connection ends after the client receives the response. Websockets allows us to keep the connection open.

If you use nodejs and websockets in the server end, you can push the events using the sockets to the clients, as opposed to the clients polling the server in certain intervals.

So it will save you from long polling.

In your case: If you decide on using nodejs and websocket then you will need to find a way to trigger an incoming email event in the server and notify the existing sockets about the event.

So node will also need to poll POP to check mail, whats the difference

Imagine 1000 users logged in to the app using polling. Each user will poll the server every 30 seconds. So 2000 POP polls per second.

Using nodejs, 2 POP poll second, and if there is any mail, notify the sockets, and the clients will handle the event.

But you should really consider the overall requirements of your project. How to decide when to use Node.js?

Thanks for the info ... i will look into socket.io .. is there any example with codeignitor? — Red, Jun 24 '12 at 15:22
+1 bronco, im kind of intoxicated right now but how about storing your values in a json file, then check the timestamp of that file, if the timestamp differs send a new request?? — Philip, Jun 25 '12 at 02:33

Long polling with codeigniter and node.js

1 Answers1